Saturday, January 15, 2005

Grains of Sand

(Wow, two posts at one time: it's kinda scary.)

Many years ago, a Greek philosopher named Eubulides of Miletus posed what has since come to be known as the Sorites (or Heap) Paradox. It goes something like this:

"One grain of sand is not a heap. So if you have one grain of sand, you do not have a heap. Now, if you add one grain of sand (which is not a heap) to something that is not a heap (your original one grain), it is still not a heap. You now have two grains of sand, which is not a heap. Add one more grain of sand (3 total), and it is still not a heap. Add another grain of sand. And another. And another. Even when you have 10,000 grains of sand, you do not have a heap. It follows that there are no heaps."

It can work in reverse, too:

"Suppose you have a heap of sand [assume 10,000 grains]. If you remove one grain of sand, you still have a heap. If you remove one more grain, you still have a heap. So one grain of sand is not a heap and does not affect whether something is or is not a heap. Continue removing grains, and you eventually have a heap of sand made up of zero (0) grains."

A modern version might look like this:

"(1) If a person has only $1, quem is not rich.
(2) One dollar less or more does not affect whether or not a person is rich.
(3) Thus, a person with $100 is not rich, nor is a person with $100,000, nor a person with $100,000,000,000,000,000, nor anyone else, for that matter: no one is rich."

And the paradox can apply to other things, as well: baldness, fullness, tallness, knowledge, etc.

There are several resolutions of the paradox:
(1) The "ideal language" proposition, which asserts that terms like "heap" and "rich" are too vague to be valid objects for logical reasoning.
(2) The "epistemic" theory, which says that terms like "heap" and "rich" contain specific "cut-off lines" that govern when the terms apply. The problem is that we can never know exactly where those cut-off lines are.
(3) The "many-valued" or "fuzzy" logic standard, which dictates that a statement can have more than two truth values (classical logic says that a statement is either "true" or "false"); thus, there are degrees of baldness, heapness, knowledge, etc.

It's interesting to think about the places you see this puzzle in life, used both ways. "Why should I vote; my one little vote won't make any difference." "Why should I help with Project X? One more person won't make any difference." "Donate money, even if it's only $1. Every little bit counts."

It's scary to think that every action we take, no matter how small, could have dire consequences somewhere down the line. At least, it's scary until we remember Romans 8:28 and other hope-giving passages. Then it's just creepy.

3 Comments:

Blogger Ma Hoyt said...

See, if you wanted to know how many grains of sand constitute a heap, you only had to ask. It's 100.

We learned that back when I went to college, a few *ahem* (garbled) years ago. The class was "Heap 101," if I remember correctly. It was a lot like "The Amusing Use and Abuse of Comedy," only drier.

(I am sooooo jealous)

8:01 PM  
Blogger Martinez said...

I'm jealous, too. I wish LU had a course about providing strict definitions for vague quantity terms. That's some useful life knowledge, that is.

And if a heap is 100, why was the class called "Heap 101?" That seems awfully misleading to me.

11:00 PM  
Blogger Ma Hoyt said...

An excellent point.

*ponders deep recesses of memory*

Well, I think it was something like this....

The school was hoping to start an honors program, so they had recruited that famous professorial tag team, "Schlobski & Wepps," to teach the first course, "Heap 101." The following year they were expected to teach, "Heap 202," then "Heap 303," and so forth.

Unfortuately, it occurred to the "powers that were," that adding one more honors course each year, would be just that. One more honors course, but never an honors program. (This HTML is so cool!)

So they said, "Hey, let's just make an arbitrary judgement and say that a heap is 100. And that way, we can have a really big pizza party, instead."

And so, it was decided, and the party was held, and poor Schlobski and Wepps ended up in a glass blowing business over in Europe.

At least, I think that's what happened.

Yeah, I'm sticking with that.

2:50 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home