"Correctness" In English
Part of our final exam in History of the English Language involved writing an essay addressing "the history, practice, value, and future of 'correct' English." I found this topic very interesting, and I was fairly pleased with my efforts. I was going to follow the example of some of my friends and post the paper here, but then I realized that I can't do that nifty page-folding thingy in Blogger. So, I shall post a few selected excerpts from the paper below. Anyone who wishes to read the paper in its entirety should email me and request a copy (or comment here), and it will be given. If you are reading this blog and don't have my email address, you should know someone who does.
Excerpts from "The Straight and Narrow: 'Correctness' in the English Language:
"During the first several hundred years of its existence, the English language underwent a large number of changes thanks to shifting political situations. As a result, it was not until the Middle English period that any serious attempts at regulation of the language were made. In the fifteenth century, the East Midland dialect of Middle English became the basis for a written standard that would eventually become a spoken standard."
"During the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, 'freewheeling' was the name of the game in usage of the English language. Efforts in the seventeenth century to establish an English Academy (an institution that would have been responsible for regulating English usage) failed, but people were still concerned with the issue of language."
"Today, as in the past, the rules of 'correct' grammar rear their heads most often in the written language. The language of formal writing, whether in schoolwork or scholarly journals, is held to a higher standard than the spoken language."
"The primary value of 'correct' grammar lies in its standardized nature. The purpose of language is communication, and having a standard system facilitates that purpose. But every distinct dialect of English works perfectly well in its own cultural context. African Americans speaking African American Vernacular English have no trouble communicating, or at least no more than two doctors speaking Standard American English do. Why, then, is the use of 'correct' English so important?"
"In some ways, learning 'proper' English is like learning a foreign language, both in method and purpose. When one is preparing to live for an extended time in a country whose native language is not English, one would be wise to make at least a cursory effort to learn that native language. One would have trouble getting by in Italy without at least a working knowledge of Italian. Likewise, one must be familiar with 'proper' English if one is to function successfully in educated society. Cooks at McDonald’s probably don’t need to know the proper use of the subjunctive tense to get by in their careers, but people who want to be university professors probably do. My personal goals more closely resemble the latter, so I must practice 'proper' English."
(Full text available upon request)

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home